The Ultimate Used Car Buying Guide – by

A step-by-step guide to finding and buying a great used car in cities like Toronto, Montreal, Vancouver, Calgary & Edmonton

HOME GUIDES The Ultimate Used Car Buying Guide – by

10 Steps to Follow When Buying a Used Car

family sedan driving at sunset
Nathan O. Resident Auto Enthusiast -

Whether you’re buying a high-end luxury car or a beater, from a dealership or a private seller, there are 10 steps to follow. 

You asked for it, and here it is—our comprehensive used car buyer’s guide.

Skip to Sections

  1. Trends in the Used Car Market
  2. How to Buy the Ideal Used Car
  3. Research Used Cars for Sale in Your Area
  4. How to Research Car Prices
  5. Getting Information from a Used Car Dealer
  6. What to Look For in an Inspection and Test Drive
  7. How to Negotiate a Used Car Purchase
  8. Finalizing a Used Car Sale
  9. How to Register a Used Car
  10. Driving Off into the Sunset


Step 1: Looks at Trends in the Used Car Market

Step 1: Trends in the Used Car Market

First, let’s take a high-level look at the used car market and how we can navigate this endlessly changing industry successfully.

How do You Buy a Used Car?

Broadly speaking, you can buy from a private seller or a dealership.

private seller is an individual who puts a car up for sale, usually on sites like Kijiji or Facebook Marketplace.

dealership gets vehicles from trade-ins, auctions, corporate fleet sales, and occasionally individual sellers. They usually offer in-house maintenance, warranties, and financing options. Used vehicles at a dealership are usually priced slightly higher than private vehicle, but with good reason: you’re buying from a licensed business that can offer you more value and assurances than a private seller ever could.

In our experience, dealerships are a far better bet than private sellers. For that reason, only lists vehicles from licensed dealers.

Browse Used Dealership Cars Near you on
Browse Used Cars

The Modern Used Car Market

Here are some facts about the modern used car market that you need to know:

  • Sales are High. In Canada, about three million used cars are sold every year, making the used car market about 1.5 times the size of the new car market. This also means that the average car has three owners before it hits the scrapyard.
  • Supply is Cyclical. Immediately after WWII, there was a surge of new car sales as soldiers came home and started families. Demand for new cars was exhausted by the 50s, and people bought used until around 1961, when the older cars finally kicked the bucket. This cycle has repeated itself four times, with the most recent surge peaking in 2016. This means that lots of relatively young cars are hitting the market right now.
  • Fleet Sales are Increasing. Because the economy is in decent shape, companies are upgrading their fleets of company or rental cars. This has increased the proportion of former rentals in the market.

From the buyer’s point of view, these are good trends. Supply is increasing faster than demand, which drives down prices in general, and fleet sales cause spikes of oversupply, leading to discounts on popular car models.

What to Know Before Buying a Used Car

However, there are some cautions you should take before buying.

  • Flood Damage. Parts of the country have been hit hard by recent flooding, and it shows in the cars for sale. Increasing numbers of cars have flood damage, and this often does not appear on CARFAX reports. Undeclared flood damage is especially a concern when buying from private sellers. Be particularly wary if buying from someone who lives in a flood zone.
  • Odometer Fraud. It’s not a myth, and it’s on the rise among private sellers. With “how-to’s” appearing all over the internet, many private sellers are cranking back their odometers before listing their cars for sale.
family sedan driving

Step 2: How to Choose the Ideal Car

Step 2: Choosing the Ideal Car

Start by building a shortlist of vehicles. Here are some tips.

Figure Out Your Budget

First, do you have the cash in your savings account? If so, your budgeting process is simple—subtract your estimated insurance and short-term maintenance costs, and the remainder is your budget.

If you don’t have the cash on hand, you will need financing. With an auto loan calculator, mess around with the sliders until you get a loan in which:

  • You pay a down payment that is at least 10% of the total cost
  • The monthly payments are affordable
  • The car is paid off within 3 years (before maintenance costs begin to increase)

Get Pre-Approved

Confirm your estimate by asking your bank or the dealer to pre-approve it. They may adjust the terms, but not unfairly. Whatever they pre-approve is a good estimate for the kind of financing you can expect.

Expert Tip: Pre-approval also gives you an upper hand in negotiations since you’ll know what price and payments you can afford.

Browse Multiple Makes and Models for used cars, trucks and SUVs.
Browse Used Cars

How Much Car is Too Much Car?

However, just because you can afford to pay a certain amount doesn’t mean you should. Consider your real needs. If you only use your car for commuting in Windsor, you probably don’t need AWD. If you are going to be hauling goods in Northern Ontario, you probably won’t get much use out of cooled seats. Be careful not to pay for something you don’t need.

The Most Popular Used Vehicles on the Market

Right now, the kings of the used vehicle market are crossovers, SUVs, and trucks with muscular engines and automatic transmissions. Here are the major movers.

Small Family Car - VW Golf

When looking at used cars, reliability and maintenance are key. The Golf is small enough to park downtown yet boasts 4 seats and lots of trunk space.

Volkswagen has been making and updating the Golf since the 70s so parts are available, cheap and everyone knows how to work on them. This means that high-mileage maintenance will be less of a pain in your wallet than going with another German classic like an older 3-series or C-class which you will find in the same price range.

Browse Used Volkswagen Golfs under $10,000 near you.

Mid-Size Sedan - Toyota Corolla

red toyota corolla

A family-friendly sedan with great fuel economy. The Corolla is one of the go-to sedans on the used market right now.

Browse Toyota Corollas under $15,000 near you.
Browse Sedans Nearby

Trucks/SUVs - Toyota Tacoma

white toyota tacoma

The Tacoma is a workhorse truck that never seems to quit. The older models are still extremely serviceable and have a long life ahead of them, and the newer ones are all but guaranteed to keep a high resale value for years to come.

Browse Toyota Tacomas under $15,000 near you.
Browse Trucks Near Me

Choosing the Right Car for Your Lifestyle

Create a list of priorities, divided into two columns, “must have” and “would be nice.” Some examples include:

  • Seats 4 comfortably
  • Seats up to 6 if you squeeze
  • AWD/4WD
  • Automatic Transmission
  • High rate of acceleration
  • Collision safety (find detailed safety ratings on the IIHS website)
  • Aesthetically pleasing

Building a Shortlist of Used Cars

Using your feature list, build a short list of 3-4 target vehicles, including, make and model. Then, build a range of acceptable years for each model. 

research used cars

Step 3: Research Used Cars for Sale in Your Area

Step 3: Researching used cars for sale in your area

Next, find used cars in your area that match the shortlist.

Private sale or Dealership?

Private sales are riskier. Common wisdom holds that you should not spend more than $5000 on a privately sold car unless you’re confident that you can trust the seller completely (i.e. if the seller is a friend or family member). We would go a little further and say that, if your money is tight and you can’t afford major losses, don’t spend more than $3000. Above that price, you should be going to a dealership.

Where to Search for a Pre-Owned Vehicle

The best place to find private sales is Kijiji or Facebook Marketplace. Because private vehicle postings there are free, most private sellers list there. The flip side is that free postings creates an open door for scammers, so be careful.

The traditional way to find a dealership is to contact each nearby dealership until you find one of the cars you want. Fortunately, technology has made this part much easier. Search your location and desired vehicle here on Carpages to quickly find all nearby options.

While the dealerships on are all accredited, they may not be the right fit for you. Look up reviews of the dealerships on DealerRater or Google Map to find out about their credibility, financing options, maintenance shops, and warranties. 

research car prices

Step 4: How to Research Car Prices

Step 4: Researching car prices

Next, it’s time to figure out what those vehicles are worth. 

Finding the Prices that Used Cars are Really Worth

The Canadian Black Book has the most precise cost estimates. In fact, its estimates are the ones used by the Ontario government to determine how much sales tax you’ll pay. Best of all, finding out car values with Canadian Black Book is free.

Expert Tip: Find Real Car Prices for Free. Use Carpages' vehicle appraisal tool to check car prices.

Use Carpages' appraisal tool to check car prices instantly
Try it!

Calculate Long Term Ownership Costs

Check out Kelley Blue Book for estimates of five-year ownership costs in U.S. dollars. Use this as a rough guide when determining whether each vehicle fits into your budget. Maintenance cost should also be factored into these calculations.

Don’t Forget the Tax

The Ontario tax on used vehicle sales is 13%, calculated using the Canadian Black Book price. It’s always paid by the buyer; never by the seller. Keep this in mind when deciding what you can afford.

close up of grey car on road

Step 5: Phone Call and VIN Check

Step 5: Contacting a Seller and Checking the VIN

Contacting a Seller

Call the seller or dealership before visiting them to make sure the car is in stock. 

What to Ask a Used Car Seller

On the phone or in person, ask a seller the following questions:

  • “What is the car’s ownership history?”
  • “Has the car been in any accidents?”
  • “Has the car had any major repairs?”
    • “What and why?”
  • “What is the mileage?”
    • The average mileage for a vehicle in Ontario is 16,000 a year. If the car’s mileage is significantly more or less than that, ask why that is.
  • “Do you offer financing?”
    • “Subprime financing?”
      • If your credit score is lower than average, you may need to apply for subprime financing. This is typically the case for people without much credit history, or who have experienced bankruptcy or divorce.
  • “Is there an outstanding loan on the car?”
  • “Have there been any recalls? Have you handled them?”
  • “What is the Vehicle Identification Number (VIN)?” This will come in handy in the next section.

H3: How to Find a Car's History

The VIN can be used to obtain a record of any car’s public history.

Running a VIN Check

Head over to Carfax and run the VIN to get a vehicle history report. If you come up with nothing, that’s very unusual. Consider double-checking the number with the seller. If they continue to give you a number not linked to any vehicle, they’re extremely shady. Walk away.

The Vehicle History Report

The Vehicle History Report will give you a ton of useful info. First, it allows you to verify that the seller was honest. Compare what the seller told you to the reported recalls and accidents. 

Second, it protects you from dishonest private sellers who might be trying to scam you. Some cars sold privately have previously been written off as total losses by insurance companies. These cars may still be drive-able, but they are marked with a “salvage title” to warn future owners. A salvage title is a strong warning that a car has hidden damages, in addition to absoluting trashing your resale value. Avoid these titles whenever possible.

If the report checks out, you’re in good shape to then test drive and inspect the vehicle yourself.

woman test driving a used car

Step 6: What to Look For in an Inspection and Test Drive

Step 6: The Test Drive and Inspection

Finally, it’s time to actually look at the car. Schedule a time for a test drive with the specific car you want.

Why an Inspection is Crucial

Not everything shows up on the Vehicle History Report. Minor accidents that didn’t result in insurance claims, interior damage, and crappy repair jobs all skate by right under Carfax’s nose. You need to be able to judge whether a car is in good enough shape.

Expert Tip: Always schedule inspections and test drives during daylight hours. Daylight makes problems with the vehicle easier to spot.

What to Look for When You Arrive 

When you arrive for your test drive, first inspect the vehicle. Look for the following red flags:

  • Paint job. Mismatched paint is a big warning sign of previous damage.
  • Frame warping. If the car doesn’t sit level or has warping under the hood, it has been in a major accident.
  • Uneven tire tread. The treads of all four tires should be equally worn. Uneven tread is a sign of deeper problems in the wheel alignment, steering, and frame. 
  • Tears on the upholstery. These are expensive to repair and should result in a discount.
  • Leaks, corrosion, or discolored fluids. Any of these are a sign of major problems in the fluid-bearing components. Transmission fluid should be pink or red, while oil should be light brown.

If the car passes your inspection, take it out for a drive.

What to Look for in a Test Drive

When driving, do these tests:

  • Fold all the seats; open up all the storage space.
  • Take a route that includes all major features—hills, curves, highway, tight residential streets, rough roads, and even country roads (if they’re a regular part of your commute).
  • Do a three-point turn to test maneuverability.
  • Accelerate quickly on a long stretch, paying attention to how much power the engine puts out.
  • Brake both slowly and quickly.
  • Take a tough hill and listen for unusual noises or vibrations.
  • Check the mirrors for blind spots.
  • Use cruise control.
  • Turn on the AC.

Third-Party Inspection

It’s never a bad idea to get a mechanic to inspect the car for you. Inspections cost about $100 but can save you thousands in unexpected maintenance.

Document Check

The seller should provide these documents:

  • the Used Vehicle Information Package (UVIP)
  • Safety Standards Certificate
  • Ontario Drive Clean Emissions Test

Without these documents, you cannot register your vehicle in Ontario. If the seller doesn’t have them, you will need to pay for new inspections ($70 for Safety Standards, $30 for Emissions).

Step 7: How to Negotiate a Used Car Purchase

Step 7: Negotiating a used car purchase

According to bargaining theory, a person’s strength in negotiation is dependent on three factors:

  • patience
  • information
  • risk tolerance

All three of these factors can be turned to your advantage.

How to Negotiate a Good Deal with a Used Car Dealership

A professional salesperson will always have more patience than you. The key to negotiating is to be patient and not rush to close the deal. Here are a couple of tips to help you negotiate your purchase:

  • Always be mentally prepared to walk away from a deal. If the salesperson tries to force you to sign too quickly, don’t give in to the pressure. This kind of high pressure sales approach is unprofessional and there are plenty of good dealers and salespeople who don’t employ this kind of approach that you can choose to work with instead.
  • If the salesperson runs through the numbers too quickly for you to understand, ask them to slow it down and repeat the numbers until you do understand them. Buying a vehicle is a big expense and you need to know what you’re buying and how much it’s going to cost you.
  • If the price of the vehicle is non-negotiable, you can sometimes negotiate add-on products such as rustproofing, winter tires, or other upgrades and accessories.
Find used cars near you on
Try it!

Maximize your risk tolerance by not shopping while desperate. If you need a car to get to work, try to figure out a carpool or transit option; that way, you won’t feel pressured to close a deal until your next shift. Also, keep in mind the other cars on your shortlist. Even if this sale falls through, you can still find a good vehicle.

At first, the dealership has more information than you. They know the car’s condition and blue book value. However, if you follow all the above steps, you’ll know that information as well. This evens out the playing ground.

Expert Tip: Some dealers have switched from a price negotiation strategy to a no-haggle policy. This means that the sticker price of the vehicle is the only price anyone will pay for that car. In this case, the vehicle is already priced as low as the dealer is willing to sell it for, no need to negotiate. When this isn’t the case, you can offer a lower price to see if you can get a better deal. If the vehicle has body damage like scratches or dents, you can point these out and ask the dealer to reduce the price based on the damage found.

How to Negotiate a Good Deal with a Private Seller

Negotiating with a private seller is very different. They are not a professional business, so their reasons for selling a vehicle and their ability and desire to negotiate will vary from one seller to the next. There are so many scenarios of why someone might be selling their vehicle, that it’s difficult to summarize how to negotiate on a private sale. 

Be careful when buying privately though, because not all private sellers are who they at first seem to be. There is a growing concern of unlicensed dealers posing as private sellers (also referred to as “curbsiders”) who may seem legit at first, but the car they’re selling might just be a salvaged piece of junk, a stolen car, or might have hidden problems. Be very cautious and use good judgment to know who it is that you’re buying from and what it is that you’re buying.

If you decide to buy privately, we highly recommend taking the vehicle to your mechanic for a full inspection prior to putting any money on the table or signing any paperwork. With private vehicle sales, there are no refunds and no guarantees. Private vehicles are sold as-is.

Step 8: Finalizing a Used Car Sale

Step 8: Finalizing a used car sale

After—and only after—you’ve settled on a price, talk about financing. Show the dealership’s finance manager your pre-approved loan if you have one. They may be able to offer you a better rate than the bank.

The finance manager may also offer you an extended warranty. Ask questions about the type of warranty they’re offering because not all warranties are created equal. If the extended warranty is from the car manufacturer, then you can be sure it’s backed by them and you shouldn’t have any trouble making claims against it. However, with third party warranty companies, you need to do a bit more research and know what you’re buying, because they often don’t provide the same coverages as a warranty that’s from the manufacturer.

How to Finalize a Used Car Sale

Before finalizing your purchase, make sure your insurance policy is in place for your new vehicle.

Browse Used Dealership Cars Near you on
Browse Used Cars

Choosing the Right Insurance for a Used Car

Call your insurance company and ask them to add your new car to your policy. If you don’t currently have a policy, be sure to choose a reputable insurance agency, as they will make sure you have the minimum necessary coverage.

Be ready with information that can net you discounts, like the car’s mileage and safety features, as well as your driving record.

The big decision to make is whether to add comprehensive coverage or collision coverage to the policy. These packages cover repairs to your car. Since it’s more expensive, it may not be worth it if you bought your car on the cheap. For example, if your car cost $5000, but collision coverage cost $500/month, you will be losing money after 10 months without an accident.

Used Car Payment Options

If the car has outstanding loans, you’ll need to contact the lender to figure out a clean transfer of title.

If the car is being financed at the dealership, you’ll save time since you can complete all the loan paperwork without having to head to the bank.

Car Sale Paperwork

Both you and the seller must sign and date a valid Bill of Sale. The seller will also give you the Original Vehicle Permit.

Step 9: How to Register a Used Car

Step 9: Registering a used car

Your car will need to be registered with the provincial Ministry of Transportation.

Registering a Newly Purchased Used Car

Typically, the dealer will complete the vehicle registration for you. If you’re buying privately and not from a dealer, you will end up having to do it yourself. Go to a Service Ontario center with the following documents:

  • The UVIP, Safety Standards Certificate, and Drive Clean Emissions test (provided by the seller in Step 5)
  • Original Vehicle Permit (provided by the seller in Step 8)
  • Proof of purchase
  • Proof of insurance coverage

Old License Plates

If you want to use your old plates, also bring the plate portion of your permit to complete the transfer.

Step 10: Driving Off into the Sunset

Step 10: Enjoy your new (used) car.

The time has come to enjoy your new ride. We recommend a long drive down country roads or by a lake. Canada is full of great scenery and cute little towns ripe for exploring!

happy couple driving off into the sunset

Go get your car and take it for a drive! Be sure to leave yourself some time to enjoy your new purchase.

Find the perfect Used Car near you in Minutes!
Used Cars for Sale